I disagree completely. Although PTSD is very real, it can pertain to anyone, military and civilians alike. It can affect that child who survived a car accident in which her parents died. It can affect students at schools where shootings took place... Behind the Purple Heart, you'll find years of tradition. You'd be ridiculous to think that our Fathers before us didn't experience the same kind of exposure, if not worse. WWI & II? Korea? Vietnam? American Soldiers were slaughtered by the masses. More exposure to incidence, and they had less support mechanisms in place than the ones we have today. There is always room for improvement for the way our Soldiers transition from the sandbox upon returning home, and dealing with the experiences they were exposed to, YES. Should we change years of tradition and alter the conditions in which we can recieve a very presigious and honorable medal? NO. How many people can you think of that CLAIM they have PTSD and were never exposed to any hostile environment? I know I can think of more than I can count on both hands.. That would be a flawed system and there would be many undeserving people walking around wearing the same medal as a gentlemen who lost his leg, or even gave his life..

Here's the bottom line. Soldiers who have PTSD need support. Assistance. Counsel. Things that will either get them in their right frame of mind to return back to the fight, or transition them out of the military where they can contribute to the workforce in other conditions best suited for them.

SSG Goede, Ryan J
3x Purple Heart Recipient