Loading...

Skip Navigation LinksHome > Support Groups > Discussion Messages
Miscellaneous :
General

This support group serves as an information center for other discussions on health topics.

 

Join this Group


 











Loading...

News Comments
Add a topic Recent discussions
Start watching this topic
Gender Row Runner Semenya Placed On Suicide Watch

South African runner Caster Semenya, who is at the center of a gender row, has been placed on suicide watch amid fears for her mental stability. ...Read More

Posted on : Monday, September 14, 2009 12:00 AM
Add reply       No of replies : 27

Report Abuse

You can help us in removing abusive content or spam.
Your Name
Your Email ID
Subject
Message
(Maximum 3000 Characters)
  
 
I am surprised that her pediatrician and parents didn't know. To let this girl grow up and not tell her was cruel. I don't think she knew. What made it worst was for her to learn this obvious secret before the world.
By the way for those of us that remember the scandals of the East Germans, it was only in recent years that these female athletes revealed that they did not know about the drugs. They thought they were being given vitamins. Many times countries keep secrets to to win medals.
Replied on Thursday, September 17, 2009 12:00 AM

lucas1
(Guest)
So Caster becomes the poster boy of the "new" South Africa. A country that once led the world in medical and transplant science - now incapable of providing the most basic medical investigation (an ultrasound) to a young person clearly showing signs of abnormal development. Instead they knowingly parade her on the world stage with the puerile hope that the world would be duped. What idiots. Like the leader Zuma believing a shower could prevent his Aids after raping a young woman. What a travesty - for a country to attain a pretense of social morality at the cost of a total loss of leadership intelligence and integrity. Welcome to the Union of Zimbabwe.
Replied on Thursday, September 17, 2009 12:00 AM

jaxxx
(Guest)
She's intersexed, people. And there's not one damned thing wrong with that. We're always trying to fit people into a narrow gender box. Not only are people physically born out of this dichotomous gender conceptualization, they are also emotionally and mentally born out of the dichotomy (or come to this place). She can choose to be and live how she wants.
Replied on Thursday, September 17, 2009 12:00 AM

davidhtom
(Guest)
If Caster goes on estrogen replacement therapy and has the internal testes removed (which should be, because they can become cancerous) then I cannot see any reason why she cannot continue her sporting career. She would then be no different to any other female-identified XY individual. There are post-transition females, identified male at birth who compete in womens sport. Renee Richards the tennis player was one, the famous golfer we heard about recently in the news another.

But you are right Trinity, it is not up to any of us how Caster proceeds with this news. She can live any way she chooses as a person.
Replied on Thursday, September 17, 2009 12:00 AM
Caster Semenya should not be placed on trial — it's our society's outmoded perspective on gender that's due for an overhaul. That race for equality won't be won until we're all free to safely cross the finish line together.
Replied on Monday, September 21, 2009 12:00 AM
 




Member Sign In

Remember me
Forgot Password?
Sign up now


Medwonders has 256201 Members and 444 Groups.
Last Updated - May 15, 2024 - Designed & Content Managed by Medindia4u.com Pvt. Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 Medindia4u.com Pvt. Ltd. All rights reserved.